Another Vietnam?
President Bush’s analogy to Iraq is not inaccurate, just incomplete.
BY MAX BOOT
Friday, August 24, 2007 12:01 a.m. EDT Ever since the mid-1970s, critics of American military involvement have warned that any decision to deploy armed forces abroad–in Lebanon and El Salvador in the 1980s, in Kuwait, Somalia, and Kosovo in the 1990s, and more recently in Iraq and Afghanistan–would result in « another Vietnam. » Conversely, supporters of those interventions have adamantly resisted any Vietnam comparisons.
President George W. Bush boldly abandoned that template with his speech to the Veterans of Foreign Wars on Wednesday. In a skillful bit of political jujitsu, he cited Vietnam not as evidence that the Iraq War is unwinnable, but to argue that the costs of giving up the fight would be catastrophic–just as they were in Southeast Asia.
This has met with predictable and angry denunciations from antiwar advocates who argue that the consequences of defeat in Vietnam weren’t so grave. After all, isn’t Vietnam today an emerging economic power that is cultivating friendly ties with the U.S.?
(Lire la suite…)